Re: Glossodoris sedna from Utila, Honduras

January 20, 2006
From: Ray Simpson

Concerning message #15600:

Regarding the message on Glossodoris sedna from Honduras... is it possible that this species is a naturally occurring West Atlantic-East Pacific species? There are numerous species that are found on both sides of Central America, why was it assumed in the first place that this species was an introduction? It seems that if this species was introduced by ballast water it would be restricted to S. Fla. and the Bahamas... I guess you have your suspicions after this recent message?

Going along with the idea, is Glossodoris restricted to the Eastern Pacific? There seems to be 3 species (G. sedna, G. baumanni, G. dalli) in the Eastern Pacific. The Malacolog database indicates that there is a species called Glossodoris moerchi in the Western Atlantic ... is this a valid species or could it be a misidentification of another genus or even G. sedna?

Appreciate your time,
Ray Simpson

P51MustNB@aol.com

Simpson, R., 2006 (Jan 20) Re: Glossodoris sedna from Utila, Honduras. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/15614

Dear Ray,
Certainly we sometimes can't be sure with species which are found in two or more disjunct geographic areas. You will see I have often discussed how difficult it is to know where some well-known hitchhikers, such as Thecacera pennigera originated. Of course others such as the lessepsian migrants are usually obvious because we know the fauna of the Mediterranean quite well.

You are of course right when you say there are species which occur naturally on both sides of the Panama Isthmus, but this does mean that all species found on both sides are naturally occurring. I guess G. sedna is considered 'native' to the east Pacific because it was first found there and has quite a wide distribution there. While G. sedna had just a limited distribution in the Florida - Bahamas region it was reasonable to assume it was an import, but the Honduras record suggests it is either spreading or perhaps may have a much wider Caribbean distribution, which could either be natural or from human intervention.

There is at least one Glossodoris in the Atlantic, G. ghanensis, but it hasn't to my knowledge reached the west Atlantic. Concerning Glossodoris moerchi. Web-based databases can be a trap as they are usually not well edited or updated. That species was originally described as Goniodoris picturata by Moerch - a preoccupied name which was later changed to Chromodoris moerchi by Bergh. The generic names in the chromodorids became terribly confused for about a hundred years and at one stage almost everything was placed in Glossodoris. Whatever its correct genus placing, the original description is not good enough to be sure what Moerch was talking about.

So to wrap up, I guess it pays to keep an open mind on some of these distributions. With our present state of knowledge it seems logical to consider G. sedna to be native to the East Pacific only, but we just don't know how good our knowledge is.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman

Rudman, W.B., 2006 (Jan 20). Comment on Re: Glossodoris sedna from Utila, Honduras by Ray Simpson. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/15614

Factsheet

Glossodoris sedna

Related messages

  1. Glossodoris sedna from Belize
    From: Robert Lee, October 3, 2007
  2. Glossodoris sedna from Costa Rica
    From: Russel Schoenhard, June 22, 2007
  3. Re: Glossodoris sedna from Turks and Caicos
    From: Florent Charpin, July 1, 2006
  4. Glossodoris sedna from Turks and Caicos
    From: Florent Charpin, June 29, 2006
  5. Glossodoris sedna near La Paz, Sea of Cortez
    From: Renee Gallo, January 20, 2006
  6. Glossodoris sedna from Utila, Honduras
    From: Les Wilk, January 19, 2006
  7. Glossodoris sedna from Revillagigedos Islands, Mexico
    From: Jack Connick, January 10, 2006
  8. Re: Glossodoris sedna in Florida again
    From: Blair Carmichael, February 25, 2005
  9. Glossodoris sedna from Galapagos Ids
    From: Julianne Parolisi, January 3, 2005
  10. Re: Glossodoris sedna from Florida
    From: Dave Behrens, July 13, 2004
  11. Glossodoris sedna from Florida
    From: Jim Lyle, July 12, 2004
  12. Glossodoris sedna in Florida again
    From: Paul Osmond, February 26, 2004
  13. Glossodoris sedna from the Sea of Cortez
    From: Rand McMeins, September 29, 2003
  14. Glossodoris sedna in Key Largo, Florida
    From: Paul Osmond, August 9, 2003
  15. Glossodoris sedna from Florida
    From: Brian Smith, May 19, 2003
  16. Glossodoris sedna from the western Atlantic
    From: Colin Redfern, November 5, 2002
  17. E. Pacific Glossodoris sedna from Florida
    From: Linda Ianniello, November 4, 2002
  18. Re: Glossodoris sedna from Costa Rica
    From: Alicia Hermosillo, June 16, 2002
  19. Glossodoris sedna from Costa Rica
    From: Peter Ajtai, June 3, 2002
  20. Glossodoris sedna from Mexico
    From: Jeff Goddard, October 13, 2000

Show factsheet and all related messages