December 18, 1999
From: Terry Gosliner
I am very interested to see Atusushi's photos of the Hypselodoris from Japanese waters. I will admit that it looks somewhat like H. bertschi, but I think it is one of the many color variants of H. maculosa. The main reason I say this is based on the differences in distribution of mantle glands in the two species. In H. bertschi, the mantle glands form a continuous line from the posterior end of the animal to about the level of the rhinophores. In H. maculosa, the glands are interrupted in the middle region of the body. The animal in Atsushi's photo appears to lack glands in the middle region. Also, in both Mike Miller's photo to which you link and the photo in Bertsch and Johnson to which you refer have obvious and continuous mantle glands. In H. bertschi the dark spots tend to be larger than those of H. maculosa and the white lines are usually much fainter in H. bertschi. It would be nice to have a specimen to examine to confirm the anatomical differences. H. bertschi has a much larger penial sac and some radular differences, as well.
There is another problem with the name of H. bertschi that Kathe Jensen pointed out to me. Bergh (1880) stated in a footnote that Pease's Hawaiian specimens had the same name as Eydoux and Souleyet's Doris lineata and needed a new name. Bergh dseignated the name Chromodoris peasei for Pease's Hawaiian animals. Therefore the species should be called Hypselodoris peasei (Bergh, 1880) rather than H. bertschi. Sorry about that Hans!
This situation was made a bit more complex by the fact that Kay and Young included an animal they identified as H. peasei, but this animal is clearly a Noumea and most likely Noumea simplex.
All the best,
firstname.lastname@example.orgGosliner, T., 1999 (Dec 18) Re: Hypselodoris bertschi. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/1689
As I said 'I may be wrong ..'. The mantle glands are clearly different, but the similarity in colour is quite amazing - especially after just discussing the similarities of Hypselodoris carnea and H. capensis.
I'll keep Atsushi's animal as Hypselodoris cf. maculosa so it doesn't get lost amongst the more 'typical' colour forms.
Thanks for clarifying the situation Terry, and its good to see the mantle glands being a very useful intrageneric character.
Hypselodoris cf. maculosa from Sri Lanka
From: Anouk Houben, October 5, 2007
Hypselodoris maculosa? - another colour variation?
From: Colin Ogden, May 15, 2007
Variations in Hypselodoris cf maculosa from Reunion Island
From: Philibert Bidgrain, September 29, 2005
Hypselodoris from South Africa
From: Colin Ogden, September 28, 2005
Hypselodoris cf. maculosa from Sulawesi
From: Lindsay Warren, March 24, 2000
Re: Hypselodoris cf. bertschi from Japan
From: Atsushi Ono, December 20, 1999
Hypselodoris cf. bertschi from Kerama Is
From: Atsushi Ono, December 17, 1999