Re: white Dendronotus frondosus

November 4, 2002
From: Jim Anderson

Dear Bill,
This may or may not be relevant, but are you aware of the paper by Mikael Tholleson [mikael.thollesson@ebc.uu.se].

• Tholleson, M. (1998) Discrimination of two Dendronotus species by allozyme electrophoresis and the reinstatement of Dendronotus lacteus (Thompson, 1840). Zoologica Scripta, 27(3): 189-195.

Kind regards,
Jim Anderson

JAnder4454@aol.com

Anderson, J., 2002 (Nov 4) Re: white Dendronotus frondosus. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/8352

Dear Jim,
Sometimes papers slip past me. I found the following summary of Mikael's project on the Malacological Society of London's website. It certainly does seem relevant, and further illustrates that we still have a lot to learn about these animals.

"Dendronotus frondosus (Ascanius, 1774) is a boreal nudibranch which appears in several colour variations. Some of these forms seem to be more distinct and the question is whether these are better regarded as separate species. In particular, I found some specimens on the Swedish West Coast that had an opaque white colour with dark purple-blackish blotches; the common Dendronotus here is brownish. As I had specimens of both colorations from the same locality, the biological species concept could be applied and tested using allozyme electrophoresis. Allozyme electrophoresis makes it possible to score the genotype as well as the alleles carried by each specimen. Under the null hypothesis that only one population is present in the sample, the genotype frequencies are expected to follow Hardy-Weinberg frequencies. That is, if we have two alleles at a particular locus with frequencies p and q (as counted from the electrophoretic analysis), the two homozygotes should be present in frequencies p2 and q2 respectively, and we should have a frequency of 2pq heterozygotes.
In the Dendronotus study, I found four loci where one allele was present in 100% of the brown specimens (i.e. all homozygotes) and another allele in 100% of the white specimens (all homozygotes for the other allele). Thus p = q = 0.5, and we expect that half of the specimens should be heterozygotes, yet none was found. As this pattern was repeated for four independent loci (Mpi, Mdh, Idh and Acp), this is strong evidence against the specimens coming from one population. Since the specimens came from dredge hauls at the same locality, they can be considered to be different species according to the biological species concept.
As this was further supported by morphological differences, I reinstated the name Dendronotus lacteus (Thompson, 1840) for the white specimens. What we should call D. frondosus remains another topic ..."
.. Tholleson, M., 1999(August) Nudibranch systematics and molecular data. [In] Bulletin of the Malacological Society of London, 33. http://socrates.edsc.ulst.ac.uk/bull/Bull33/b33.html.

Thanks,
Bill Rudman

Rudman, W.B., 2002 (Nov 4). Comment on Re: white Dendronotus frondosus by Jim Anderson. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/8352

Related messages

  1. Re: Dendronotus dalli from Alaska
    From: Marianne Lawrence, February 19, 2008
  2. Re: Dendronotus frondosus? from British Columbia
    From: Jackie Hildering & Louisa Bates, September 24, 2007
  3. Dendronotus frondosus and eggs
    From: Kevin Lee, September 11, 2007
  4. Dendronotus frondosus from California
    From: Kevin Lee, September 11, 2007
  5. Dendronotus frondosus from Monterey, California
    From: Clinton Bauder, June 11, 2007
  6. Dendronotus frondosus from Portland, UK
    From: Etienne Lorrain, July 25, 2006
  7. Re: Dendronotus subramosus from Monterey, CA
    From: Dave Behrens, September 15, 2005
  8. Dendronotus subramosus from Monterey, CA
    From: Clinton Bauder, September 9, 2005
  9. Bushy-backed Sea Slug behaviour
    From: Herb Segars, July 20, 2005
  10. Re: Dendronotus frondosus? from Norway
    From: Kåre Telnes, February 9, 2003
  11. Re: Dendronotus frondosus? from Norway
    From: Jussi Evertsen, February 9, 2003
  12. Re: Dendronotus frondosus? from Norway
    From: Alan Shepard, February 9, 2003
  13. Dendronotus frondosus? from Norway
    From: Kåre Telnes, February 4, 2003
  14. White Dendronotus frondosus from Canada
    From: Bill Rudman, November 2, 2002
  15. Dendronotus frondosus? from British Columbia
    From: Marli Wakeling, June 18, 2002
  16. Tiny Dendronotus from southern Maine
    From: Paul Young, June 29, 2001
  17. Re: New England Dendronotus
    From: Jussi Evertsen, June 29, 2001
  18. Dendronotus sp? from New England
    From: Paul Young, June 24, 2001
  19. Re: Dendronotus frondosus size
    From: Marli Wakeling, October 31, 2000
  20. Dendronotus frondosus from Canada
    From: Marli Wakeling, October 30, 2000
  21. Dendronotus dalli from British Columbia
    From: Marli Wakeling, October 27, 2000
  22. Feeding in Dendronotus frondosus
    From: Caitlin Hammond, September 16, 2000
  23. Dendronotus frondosus from the Netherlands
    From: Peter H. van Bragt , September 6, 1999
  24. Dendronotus frondosus from the Netherlands
    From: René Lipmann, September 1, 1999
  25. Re: Dutch name for Dendronotus
    From: René Lipmann, September 1, 1999

Show factsheet and all related messages