Re: Trapania brunnea from Bare Island, Sydney

September 15, 2005
From: Nicholas Missenden

Thankyou for the id [message #14738 ]:
I didn't know that was the common name for this nudi. I used a resource book to id it and hence that's where I got the name from. Thanks again for giving me the correct name.
Regards
Nick

njmpm@iinet.net.au

Missenden, N.J., 2005 (Sep 15) Re: Trapania brunnea from Bare Island, Sydney. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/14774

Dear Nick,
I hope you didn't think I was criticising you. Clearly you have been a victim of an author or editor 'dumbing down' their publication. I have fairly strong views on the use of common names, because they are so confusing and are seldom 'common' in the sense of  'commonly used'. They are usually made up by authors on the insistence of editors on the mistaken assumption that readers are too dumb to use scientific names. One of the reasons scientific names were invented was to provide a universal name for each species which would be understood in all languages. Trapania brunnea applies to only one species, but Brown Trapania could mean 3 or 4 species at least. The best example of the confusion common names create are the names for fish in Australia and New Zealand where one species can have 5 or 6 different common names and so fisherman from NSW and Western Australia can't effectively communicate. I don't believe divers and naturalists are too dumb to use scientific names, despite the push by editors and authors to brainwash them into thinking they are.

Best wishes,
Bill Rudman

Rudman, W.B., 2005 (Sep 15). Comment on Re: Trapania brunnea from Bare Island, Sydney by Nicholas Missenden. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/14774

Factsheet

Trapania brunnea

Related messages

  1. Trapania brunnea from sthn Queensland
    From: Gary Cobb, October 26, 2009
  2. Re: Trapania brunnea from Bare Island, Sydney N.S.W
    From: Leanne and David Atkinson, October 22, 2009
  3. Re: Trapania brunnea from Bare Island, Sydney N.S.W
    From: Nick Missenden, October 19, 2009
  4. Radular morphology of Trapania brunnea [2]
    From: Bill Rudman, March 12, 2008
  5. Radular morphology of Trapania brunnea [1]
    From: Bill Rudman, March 12, 2008
  6. Trapania brunnea from Bare Island, Sydney N.S.W
    From: Nicholas Missenden, September 14, 2005
  7. Trapania brunnea from New Zealand
    From: Ross Armstrong, July 13, 2004
  8. Trapania brunnea from S.E. Australia (2)
    From: John Chuk, March 4, 2002
  9. Trapania brunnea from S.E. Australia
    From: John Chuk, February 17, 2002

Show factsheet and all related messages