January 20, 2000
From: Mary Jane Adams
Can you identify this nudibranch? It was about 2 cm. long. I found it at 12 meters on a silty sand slope in Milne Bay Province, Papua New Guinea on March 1, 1999.
Mary Jane Adams
firstname.lastname@example.orgAdams, M.J., 2000 (Jan 20) Chromodoris from Papua New Guinea. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/1751
Dear Mary Jane,
I think this is an at present unnamed species of Chromodoris. It is very similar in colour to the various colour forms of Chromodoris tinctoria.
Since I have been studying chromodorids for many years, why haven't I already named it? It's quite a good example of how most taxonomists work these days. It is very tempting to pick all the 'easy' new species and rush out and name them all, as though naming new species is some sort of race or competition. Unless there is some overriding reason for a once-off name, such as sorting out a nomenclatural problem with an important or common species, most responsible taxomomists these days describe new species in the context of broader reviews, so new species can be compared and justified. Like most taxonomists, I have a filing cabinet full of drawings and notes on species I dissected years ago but have put aside until further information on related species becomes available.
This species of yours is a good example. i have known of it for about 20 years. There are many names in the scientific literature for animals with a similar colour pattern to your species. By gradually building up records and seeing photos and specimens from throughout the Indo-West Pacific, I am now pretty sure most refer to Chromodoris tinctoria but there are one or two which are still problematic and could refer to the species in your photo. So when I refer to a photo that appears in the Forum as an unnamed species it doesn't mean that it is unknown to science, it often means we are still 'working on it'.